Liverpool FC Forum

GYBS wrote:Gotta agree think Milner is better than pennant and would of preferred we did get milner instead of pennant . At the moment in prem think young would be a good shout for right side

Yooj Bigullz wrote:

GYBS wrote:Gotta agree think Milner is better than pennant and would of preferred we did get milner instead of pennant . At the moment in prem think young would be a good shout for right side

I really like what I've seen from Young. I was surprised Villa paid so much though it could turn out to be money very well spent. I shudder to think what valuation O'Neill would place on him right now

stmichael wrote:Milner is completely overrated. The fact that he's still playing for the England u21's at 23 says it all. The Geordies up here couldn't wait to get rid, especially for £12m which was quite frankly ludicrous. We bang on about Kuyt. Well Milner at Newcastle scored 8 GOALS IN 4 YEARS.

Milner, striker converted into a winger. I'm spotting a trend on here today.

Yooj Bigullz wrote:

GYBS wrote:Gotta agree think Milner is better than pennant and would of preferred we did get milner instead of pennant . At the moment in prem think young would be a good shout for right side

I really like what I've seen from Young. I was surprised Villa paid so much though it could turn out to be money very well spent. I shudder to think what valuation O'Neill would place on him right now

GYBS wrote:

aCe' wrote:

GYBS wrote:this thread is about pennant not kuyt (but kuyt has created more , had more assists and scored more than pennant playing from the right )

i highly doubt that he created more and had more assists...
surely if u put kuyt down the right in a 4-4-2 and pennant down the right in a 4-4-2 Pennant can create dozens more from crosses and cut backs..etc etc...
kuyt might score more not enough to make him a good player or option in that position... if we play voronin down the right in a 4-4-2 he'd score more and create less too... get the picture ?!

kuyt is an absolute joke in that position whether u agree with me on that or not .. forget about kuyt and pennant for a sec.
just let me get one thing straight.. ur trying to tell me that a player who has:
a) good pace
b) good crossing
c) good dribbling

shouldnt play because kuyt who is A HARD WORKER deserves that spot more ? based on what ? and plz dnt bring stats into it !

Its all well and good having good pace and dribbling and crossin , but no point if you dont do it on a consistent enough basis of which is what pennant never was . speedy had great pace could cross and dribble but never did it when it matter. Lost count the amount of times i have seen pennant under hit or over hit a cross missing anyone who is in the box .

Think someone posted it - pennant had 6-8 assists where as kuyt had 10 -13 .

Complete lack of understanding of the game.

Fo Dne wrote:

GYBS wrote:

aCe' wrote:

GYBS wrote:this thread is about pennant not kuyt (but kuyt has created more , had more assists and scored more than pennant playing from the right )

i highly doubt that he created more and had more assists...
surely if u put kuyt down the right in a 4-4-2 and pennant down the right in a 4-4-2 Pennant can create dozens more from crosses and cut backs..etc etc...
kuyt might score more not enough to make him a good player or option in that position... if we play voronin down the right in a 4-4-2 he'd score more and create less too... get the picture ?!

kuyt is an absolute joke in that position whether u agree with me on that or not .. forget about kuyt and pennant for a sec.
just let me get one thing straight.. ur trying to tell me that a player who has:
a) good pace
b) good crossing
c) good dribbling

shouldnt play because kuyt who is A HARD WORKER deserves that spot more ? based on what ? and plz dnt bring stats into it !

Its all well and good having good pace and dribbling and crossin , but no point if you dont do it on a consistent enough basis of which is what pennant never was . speedy had great pace could cross and dribble but never did it when it matter. Lost count the amount of times i have seen pennant under hit or over hit a cross missing anyone who is in the box .

Think someone posted it - pennant had 6-8 assists where as kuyt had 10 -13 .

Complete lack of understanding of the game.