Page 4 of 4
Posted:
Wed Feb 01, 2006 2:41 pmby Ola Mr Benitez
We don't want to play Garcia down the right... he has proven he is ineffective when played there as he gives the ball away too much. I agree with Judge.. Garcia's best postion is just behind the forward/s. Fowler is not going to be able to play a full 90 mins (not for 4 - 6 weeks anyway), anyone thinking he is is, is dillusional, so I would set the team out like this...
Reina
Finnan Carra Hypia Risse
Gerrard Alonso Hamman/Sissoko Kewell
Garcia/Fowler Crouch
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 11:24 amby dawson99
pongolle was never strong enough for 90 minutes week in week out. thats why hes gone on loan.
cisse, altho everyone hates him on here it seems, is the best choice (when stevie is in the middle)
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 11:26 amby flipmode
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 11:44 amby darwisigila
cisse on the right....yes..along rafa and paco
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 11:45 amby darwisigila
at liverpool bench
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 12:04 pmby woof woof !
bigmick wrote:Cisse eh? ................ we could make him into a right winger? .......
BigMick ,months ago I wrongly advocated the use of Cisse playing wide on the right , thinking his blistering pace would bring enourmous dividends in that role . Since then however Cisse has played wide on the right and his consistent failure to cross a decent ball allied to his apparent inability to run with the ball (as opposed to running onto one ) has convinced me that no way can the fella play effectively in that position.
Cisse's best position is an out and out target man playing in a somewhat similar fashion to Owen under Houllier .Sitting up high on the shoulder of the opponents defence ,waiting for a ball to be pumped over the top, I'm sure thats what Houllier had in mind when he signed Cisse .
Rafa's vision is different and Cisse just doesn't seem to have the ability or even desire to adapt to it .
Posted:
Fri Feb 03, 2006 12:55 pmby Scottbot
woof woof ! wrote:Cisse's best position is an out and out target man playing in a somewhat similar fashion to Owen under Houllier .Sitting up high on the shoulder of the opponents defence ,waiting for a ball to be pumped over the top, I'm sure thats what Houllier had in mind when he signed Cisse .
Rafa's vision is different and Cisse just doesn't seem to have the ability or even desire to adapt to it .
That pretty much sums it up Woof although i wonder how GH was figuring to play Owen and Cisse togother in the same team. It would have been interesting. I really don't see the boss giving Cisse a great deal of playing time out on the right and imagine Stevie will keep doing the job for most of the season with Garcia getting the odd game here and there.
I agree it's an optimistic thread and just maybe, if Cisse was willing to undergo a complete makeover he could learn a new position and have some success. But his track record in France playing up-front and ego will prevent that from ever happening. Despite the criticism he recieved, Diouff did a fair job on the right at times for us and John is right when he says Diouff had/has an excellent 1st touch. Unfortunately Diouff couldn't shoot, couldn't cross and wasn't particularly quick. Cisse (as we all know) has two concrete feet and it's unlikely his first touch will get much better than it currently is.
I agree we are all hoping Cisse can play a blinder at the World Cup a sit's the only way we're gonna get more than 5mill for him. I'm still completely baffled as to why Rafa didn't send Cisse on loan to Marseilles and keep Pongo who is the better player despite not reaching anywhere near his full potential. I can only imagine that Cisse does good things in training and rafa lives in the hope that he might one day be able to produce the same on matchday.
