Liverpool FC Forum

Fo Dne wrote:The fact is though, no-one knows what actually happened in this particular incident. FACT!

Number 9 wrote:

Fo Dne wrote:

Number 9 wrote:1. So are you trying to say a two footed tackle makes him as bad as Barton..who kicks feck outta people on the floor of McDonalds,

2. punches the head of a team mate,

3. stubbed a cigar on a fellas eye?

4. Tackles are not the subject here..its about an alleged incident that he is innocent of until proven guilty.

What are ya talking about dirty tackles for anyway?Lots of players do them at times..its part of football!Feck all to do with this!

1. It was outside McDonalds and he was reacting to getting loads of some blurt. All he done is react like 90% of the poputation would. Its all well and good saying he's paid not to react, you'd be right if you said it, but lets face it, if someones abusing your family and calling you for alsort for nothing when you're out on the ale minding you're business you're going to tell em to off or do something about it. Anyone who says they wouldn't are either lying or are a wimp.

2. You were not there and don't know what happened. How do you know he wasn't simply reacting to provocation like Gerrard supposedly was?

3. Can't defend that. Stupidity.

4. There is a difference in a bad tackle and common assault. A two footed jump off the ground and stamp is an attempt to break someones legs. Nothing more nothing less.

So you were outside McDonalds and know what happened?...OK

The difference here is Barton done it...Gerrard has only been charged...Innocent till proven guilty.

Common assault..OK,lets put police beside the 4th official at every game to arrest players for dirty tackles from now on.WTF are you talking about tackles for anyway,its not the issue here!

Only Stu could turn a thread about Gerrard into Barton vs Gerrard thread.
Barton is a scumbag..FACT had he not been a footballer he'd most probably be inside for a very longtime.He's scum and has had more chances than he deserves.

But you think he's a great player so he's a top man!

Fo Dne wrote:

NANNY RED wrote:

Fo Dne wrote:

NANNY RED wrote:

Fo Dne wrote:Imagine if Joey Barton had done this the fuss it would have kicked up.

If he's glassed someone he deserves locking up. If he's smacked some bellend who gave him abuse this country's a joke.

Simple as that.

Erm Joey Barton is a thug Stu. How many times has he kicked off , even with his own team mates hes a disgrace an should not even be compared to Gerrard

Gerrard's kicked off a good few times and can be just as hot headed so don't be goin down that route.

Some of the things Gerrard's done his Career on the pitch are just as bad as the things Barton's done. Gerrard's gone in more than once too break peoples legs and hurt them and denying that is being a fool.

As for him kicking off at his own team mate, again you don't actually know what happened and were not there. To be honest, you don't even have one side of the story so don't judge.

Dont be soft Stu , Thats a stupid comment to make I thought you were better than that. You can defend Barton all you want but at the end of the day hes a .house ,who stubs ciggys out on young lad face . Yeh that was a joke , And the pic of the team mate , never happened . An him stamping all over the lad in town was made up. I know his family an all Stu an im still saying the same thing,

I know i wasnt there your right,  but dont be blinded just because Barton played for your team when he was a kid. You know as well as i do his character is completly different from Gerrards,

There Characters aren't completely different though Nanny, thats what makes them so similar on the pitch. The only real difference is Gerrard has shown he can excercise maximum control over his actions. Barton's probably got the control of a normal average lad.

The ciggy incident happened when he was kid.

The Maccies incident and Dabo one were both in retaliation to abuse or circumstances much like Gerrard's.

My points clear, how can you say Barton's a thug for reacting, but Gerrard isn't.

I'm not calling Gerrard a thug, I'm not saying Barton isn't one, Joey loses his cool far to easily, but Gerrard, I know for a fact is just as capable of seeing red and isn't an angel himself.

I personally think this country's gone mad with people like Emerald red who are all do gooders, if Gerrard and Barton were provoked then for me they were well within there rights to smack someone.

The fact is though, no-one knows what actually happened in this particular incident. FACT!

Alex G. wrote:I think Rafa is going to punish Gerrard with some games out. He doesn´t tolerate this kind of behaviours especially with a captain who should set a good example for the youngster players. Ask Pennant.

GYBS wrote:and if thats the case emerald then gerrard has done feck all wrong , his charges will be dropped and he can concentrate on winning the title for us and i hope that is the case . I expect we all do . Just got to wait and see now .

Ciggy wrote:

Fo Dne wrote:The fact is though, no-one knows what actually happened in this particular incident. FACT!

It is also a FACT you know fuck all about my upbringing.

NANNY RED wrote:Its doing my head in why its now gone to a glass being used in the face . That glass on the floor was most prob broken in what ever scrap to place. Just because theres glass on the fllor dosnt mean someone has used it. The lads took a smack i donot believe for one minute any bottle or glass has been used..

Go into any pub in Liverpool an you will see glass on the floor

Emerald Red wrote:Agree with you there. Barton is on video battering a practically helpless victim, whereas Gerrard is reported to have "brushed passed his victim" and accidently "struck him with his elbow". I can see how this can easily happen. F*ck knows what happened. Maybe the so called poor "victim" tried to grab at Gerrard and his mates jumped to his defense, in which case I say fair f*cking play to them.

Battering a helpelss victim?

He smacked some tit who was calling him and his family for alsorts lad.

If Gerrard accidently brushed passed someone and caught them with an elbow do you really think he'd be charged with ABH and Affray? 

Like I said, you don't have a clue about either incident.

Fo Dne wrote:I know that you think its ok to assault another human being because of alegiances to a football team or city.

Says it all.

NANNY RED wrote:Its doing my head in why its now gone to a glass being used in the face . That glass on the floor was most prob broken in what ever scrap to place. Just because theres glass on the fllor dosnt mean someone has used it. The lads took a smack i donot believe for one minute any bottle or glass has been used..

Go into any pub in Liverpool an you will see glass on the floor

Ciggy wrote:

Fo Dne wrote:I know that you think its ok to assault another human being because of alegiances to a football team or city.

Says it all.

WTF are you on about fuck off and stalk someone else you weirdo.

Don't flatter yourself.