Lando_Griffin wrote:I truly love the fact that the people who slate the gaffer for playing Keane and Gerrard "out of position" are now advocating doing so with Agger...
You couldn't make it up...
GYBS wrote:Two out of the back four playing out of position ? no thanks mate . carra and agger both stay in the centre for me and arbeloa stays right back - left back its between fabio,insua and dossena .
Ace Ventura wrote:Is this thread in danger of turning into joke of the year or what ?
Not aimed at you devaney...i personally agree Agger could do a decent job at left back and would be a major improvement on Dossena, with Aurellio unable to steer clear of injuries its something worth considering (once Skyrtl is back fit that is)
No i mean gybs saying Agger is or was better than Ferdinand and Carvalho, thats absolute madness imo.
Then statman owzat saying that he could be a better defensive midfielder than Mascherano, what next ?
Better keeper than Reina, better forward than Torres
GYBS wrote:Ace Ventura wrote:Is this thread in danger of turning into joke of the year or what ?
Not aimed at you devaney...i personally agree Agger could do a decent job at left back and would be a major improvement on Dossena, with Aurellio unable to steer clear of injuries its something worth considering (once Skyrtl is back fit that is)
No i mean gybs saying Agger is or was better than Ferdinand and Carvalho, thats absolute madness imo.
Then statman owzat saying that he could be a better defensive midfielder than Mascherano, what next ?
Better keeper than Reina, better forward than Torres
Im sorry but whats wrong with thinking agger is better than rio and carvahlo when he is playing to his best ? thats exactly what i think .
Ace Ventura wrote:GYBS wrote:Ace Ventura wrote:Is this thread in danger of turning into joke of the year or what ?
Not aimed at you devaney...i personally agree Agger could do a decent job at left back and would be a major improvement on Dossena, with Aurellio unable to steer clear of injuries its something worth considering (once Skyrtl is back fit that is)
No i mean gybs saying Agger is or was better than Ferdinand and Carvalho, thats absolute madness imo.
Then statman owzat saying that he could be a better defensive midfielder than Mascherano, what next ?
Better keeper than Reina, better forward than Torres
Im sorry but whats wrong with thinking agger is better than rio and carvahlo when he is playing to his best ? thats exactly what i think .
Its all about opinions mate, am not going to go all stu the red and call you clueless as Agger on his day is a top defender.
But IMHO, Carvalho and Ferdinand are about the best you will get, both far better in the air, both quicker, both physically stronger, in general better with most attributes i personally think.
I dont think i have ever seen either of them dominated by one player as much as Drogba did Agger the other season at Stamford bridge, there is no shame in that as Drogba at that time was very hard to play against. But what i mean is those two wouldnt of been given the same torrid time.
Put it one way if you swapped them for Agger i think you would see the difference in quality.
Cool Hand Luke wrote:Ace Ventura wrote:GYBS wrote:Ace Ventura wrote:Is this thread in danger of turning into joke of the year or what ?
Not aimed at you devaney...i personally agree Agger could do a decent job at left back and would be a major improvement on Dossena, with Aurellio unable to steer clear of injuries its something worth considering (once Skyrtl is back fit that is)
No i mean gybs saying Agger is or was better than Ferdinand and Carvalho, thats absolute madness imo.
Then statman owzat saying that he could be a better defensive midfielder than Mascherano, what next ?
Better keeper than Reina, better forward than Torres
Im sorry but whats wrong with thinking agger is better than rio and carvahlo when he is playing to his best ? thats exactly what i think .
Its all about opinions mate, am not going to go all stu the red and call you clueless as Agger on his day is a top defender.
But IMHO, Carvalho and Ferdinand are about the best you will get, both far better in the air, both quicker, both physically stronger, in general better with most attributes i personally think.
I dont think i have ever seen either of them dominated by one player as much as Drogba did Agger the other season at Stamford bridge, there is no shame in that as Drogba at that time was very hard to play against. But what i mean is those two wouldnt of been given the same torrid time.
Put it one way if you swapped them for Agger i think you would see the difference in quality.
Yakubu has made Carvalho look quite the fool on a few occasions. I remember the Yak completely dominated him a couple of years back at the Riverside when Boro ran out 3-0 winners and Carvalho had a nightmare.
Saying that, if I was picking my dream centre back partnership from current Premiership players it would probably be Carvalho and Ferdinand.
I don’t think Agger’s form has been as bad as some have made out, he has got stronger and stronger recently and our defensive record has been excellent bar the Hull game, and he didn’t even play in that game.
Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 198 guests
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.