by stmichael » Wed Jul 21, 2004 12:21 pm
Rafa is entitled to look at all of his squad, on an equal footing and then decide who is good, bad or indifferent.
Many would like to have seen certain players out on their ear the day Benitez walked in the door....fair enough in some respects (for those of us who have suffered them over the past few years), but if Benitez can see something in even one of them then their 'chance' (i.e a couple of weeks of training) has paid off.
I can't see much good coming out of the likes of biscan, and ultimately I think they'll all be moved on (or kept as second reserve at best if we can't find a buyer)...but in terms of 'second chance' I would consider that to be Benitez at least having a look at them.
Players such as Smicer could perform well under Benitez. I dont think there is much doubt that Smicer has ability (we have all seen flashes of his genius), the fact is that he has never showed it consistently enough. His problem is... he is not a central midfielder (cant tackle), but is not a striker. He is an "in the hole" player.
Under Houllier we did not have a place for such a player (even though we had about 5 of them ) but depending upon RB's tactics, there may be some sort of role for Smicer to play.
Now ... i wouldnt be at all upset if he left, but I think he will stay, and could be a useful squad player!!