Liverpool FC Forum

CharmlessMan wrote:I'm not splitting hairs, when anyone mentions The Beatles those who know their music and have learnt to appreciate all members of the group and that goes for any band.  Two members don’t make a band.

Smeg wrote:This may sound shocking but, apart from your obvious tracks; she loves you, i wanna hold your hand, i aint heard the Beatles.

woof woof ! wrote:

Smeg wrote:This may sound shocking but, apart from your obvious tracks; she loves you, i wanna hold your hand, i aint heard the Beatles.

Smeg ! I have to ask . How can you only have heard early Beatles hits and yet be completely unexposed to their other stuff ?

Christ even if you were violently against their music there's hardly anyway you could fail to hear it .

(eg. First time I accidently heard "here comes the sun" was in a shi'tty restaurant in Khandahar 1971 )

Khandahar = sh!t hole   

CharmlessMan wrote:I'm not splitting hairs, when anyone mentions The Beatles those who know their music and have learnt to appreciate all members of the group and that goes for any band.  Two members don’t make a band.

Christ you can't half talk some boll'ox , are you suggesting that the "Beatles" didn't need Lennon/Mcartney    

As for " those who know their music and have learnt to appreciate all members of the group and that goes for any band" The inference is that I don't know music . Guess what sunshine , I was in the music biz when you where just fluid in your old mans nutsack.

For what it's worth (not referring to Buffalo Springfield ) I have every respect for Harrison and Starr, I rate Harrisons solo work higher than that of the rest of the band . but thats just my personal taste .

coddy wrote:

woof woof ! wrote:

Smeg wrote:This may sound shocking but, apart from your obvious tracks; she loves you, i wanna hold your hand, i aint heard the Beatles.

Smeg ! I have to ask . How can you only have heard early Beatles hits and yet be completely unexposed to their other stuff ?

Christ even if you were violently against their music there's hardly anyway you could fail to hear it .

(eg. First time I accidently heard "here comes the sun" was in a shi'tty restaurant in Khandahar 1971 )

Khandahar = sh!t hole   

  yeah ? but you weren't there in '71 . (Peace hotel , with the "not for export hash "         

stmichael wrote:Top five Ringo:

I Wanna Be Your Man
With A Little Help From My Friends
What Goes On
Yellow Submarine
Honey Don`t

Top Five George:

While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Something
I Me Mine
Here Comes The Sun
Think For Yourself

Top Five John:

Strawberry Fields Forever
In My Life
Come Together
A Day In The Life
I Am The Walrus

Top Five Paul:

Helter Skelter
Back In The U.S.S.R
Here, There and Everywhere
I`ve Just Seen A Face
Blackbird

B'stard now I'm gonna have to spend hours going through my collection   

Agree with many of your choices but off the top of my head would sub

Ringo ," I wanna be you man " for "Act Naturally"

George, "I me mine" and "Think for yourself " for  " I want to tell you " and  "Within you, Without you"

John, "Come together" and "I am the Walrus" for  " Tomorrow never knows " and "All you need is love "

Paul, "Helter Skelter", "Here there and Everywhere" & " Blackbird " for  "Rocky Racoon" , " Eleanor Rigby " & " Got to get you into my life "

woof woof ! wrote:

CharmlessMan wrote:I'm not splitting hairs, when anyone mentions The Beatles those who know their music and have learnt to appreciate all members of the group and that goes for any band.  Two members don’t make a band.

Christ you can't half talk some boll'ox , are you suggesting that the "Beatles" didn't need Lennon/Mcartney    

As for " those who know their music and have learnt to appreciate all members of the group and that goes for any band" The inference is that I don't know music . Guess what sunshine , I was in the music biz when you where just fluid in your old mans nutsack.

For what it's worth (not referring to Buffalo Springfield ) I have every respect for Harrison and Starr, I rate Harrisons solo work higher than that of the rest of the band . but thats just my personal taste .

CharmlessMan wrote:you cannot have a band with just two people, and to me all the Beatles were just as special as the next member.

  Even Ringo ?  (considering that the rest of the group aren't sure whether it was Ringo or a session musician on many of the tracks that were finally cut to disc ) .

(Think I'm wasting my time here , come back when you actually have something valid to say , in the meantime 
  )

ps , How's Karim ?   

CharmlessMan wrote:Well if you didn't have Ringo who else would you have had?

Bongo Applebury  ,

 

Who's ignorant now ?   

Smeg wrote:

peewee wrote:the smiths  'heaven knows i'm miserable now' and lets not forget 'hang the dj'

oh yes now i can see where you guys are coming from, i dont know what i was thinking when i said lennon and mcCartney are better.

oh yes i do, i was thinking what utter bollox   

Its called Panic, not hang the dj.


This may sound shocking but, apart from your obvious tracks; she loves you, i wanna hold your hand, i aint heard the Beatles.