stu_the_red wrote:Effes wrote:Ye, I DID say , that he's great as in an "example to the team".
But I think he's too quiet on the pitch - personality wise, not footballing wise.
STU, you have a go at people about not having a footballing arguement and then you post that?
So come on, I know you like to voice your opinion.
Why would you have SG as captain and not Carra?
They're both winners, they're both vocal they're both from Liverpool.
In favour of Carragher he's older.
In favour of Gerrard he's in the area where he can have more of an impact on different types of games and he's a far better player and he's got more experience.
Gerrard's the better choice.
I'm not saying Carragher's a bad choice, but Gerrard is the better of the two.
Agreed, and a good point, there is 2 leaders out there, one in defence one in the middle........if only we had someone up front!