devaney » Mon Feb 14, 2022 7:35 am wrote:Eagle » Sun Feb 13, 2022 11:22 pm wrote:electrum » Sun Feb 13, 2022 5:49 pm wrote:Terrible conditions and a turgid performance.
Firmino has been a great servant to the club but he is well past his best and shouldn't be anywhere near the first 11 based on the last 12 months levels.
Gave the ball away a shocking number of times and contributed nothing going forward.
Time for him to move on in the summer.
From all of our midfielders and attackers who started the game, only Keita (90%) had a better pass completion than Firmino (84%).
I am really not sure what those stats tell us because neither of them were particularly effective during the game. Is it that both of them mainly play very short unadventurous passes?
Primarily what it tells us is that Firmino did not "give the ball away a shocking number of times" as electrum had suggested. It’s become a bit of a lazy narrative around Firmino. If he did, then most of our other players did too.
On Firmino in general, I do think there has been a decline over the last few years but I thought he was fine yesterday. With the role he is asked to play as a number 9 (make runs away from the goal to create space for others, pick up the ball in difficult spaces and try to connect the rest of the team to the last line, etc), he’ll always be questioned. If you go back a few years on this forum you’ll find people saying we should replace him with a goal scorer but he remained one of the first names on the team sheet for Klopp. I still think he’s a great option in our attack even if he doesn’t make our strongest 11 anymore.
On Keita, he didn’t pull up any trees yesterday but I thought he was quietly effective next to Fabinho and helped us control the game both on and off the ball. When it comes to the number of touches of the ball, pass completion rate, and tackles made, he came up ahead of our other midfielders. He kept giving players an option and getting them out of trouble and just kept the ball moving nicely. Off the ball he closed down spaces and helped out the fullbacks a lot. It was a very Wijnaldum type performance and we all know the sort stick Gini got over his entire 5 years with the club. When Keita came in we saw a player who liked to dribble pass players and try a risky pass but that doesn’t seem to be what Klopp is asking him to do anymore.
So I’d think that Klopp would say that both Firmino and Keita were effective yesterday in a difficult game without setting the place alight. But then neither did anyone else.