Liverpool FC Forum

Mingolet - 6. Massive liability even when we are winning.
Gomez - 6 Got nudged out for the goal too easy.
Matip - 7. finally got his goal.
Klavan - 6 maybe with regular games he might sharpen up.
Moreno - 5. Falls over like a bag of rocks everytime he is touched. More concerned about rolling around rather than retrieving the ball and that was a pathetic attempt at a block for the goal we conceded.
Can - 6 worked extremely hard.
Wijnaldum - 6. Likewise.
Ox - 7. Good game from him, nothing amazing but decent performance.
Mane - 7. nice to see him back and although he looks fit he was a little off.
Salah - 9. He's been phenomenal since coming in  Should have had a hat trick but still keeps going. Looking like he really enjoys it here 
Firmino - 7. Worked really hard and on the 70th minute took off on a run reminiscent of fat Ronaldo tearing through lads    till in front of goal when it turned all Firmino on him 

Milner - 4.
Solanke - 4.
Lovren shouldn't have been brought on with 5 minutes to go and winning 3-1 .

Mignolet -5 Could have done much better for their goal ,bugs the f*ck out of me the way he comes out virtually on his haunches flapping his arms to block any threat.
Gomez-7 Mistake for the goal ,but that shouldnt deter from a competent performance for a young player still learning his game. 
Matip -7 took his chance well when it arrived,Ive seen them chances missed,but he placed it like a striker.
Klavan-6 Slow,but benefited from playing with a more  compact defense.
Moreno-7 I thought from a purely defensive perspective it was his best game for a few seasons.
Can -5 Weakest link in the midfield his application was lacking and I think this much publicized contract wrangle has had a detrimental effect on his game.
Wijnaldum-8 Went about his game with a real purpose,Can should take notice.
Chamberlain-7 Growing into the shirt
Mane-7 two assists and looked more dangerous the more the game went on
Salah- 9 We may soon have to stave of the cherry pickers who come looking for the best.
Firmino-9 Absolutely phenomenal work rate and I still have drool on my chin following his sumptuous turn and run to set up Chamberlain.

Liverpool v West Ham
Mignolet - 5
Gomez- 5 
Matip - 6
Klavan- 6
Moreno- 7
Can - 6
Wijnaldum - 6
Chamberlain - 7
Mane- 8
Salah- 9 
Firmino- 8

Mingolet - 6 agree with RBG, he doesnt make himself big enough in one-on-one situations
Gomez - 6 completely lost his bearings for the goal, otherwise did well
Matip - 7 played well and weighed in with a goal
Klavan - 7 looked surprisingly solid
Moreno - 7 played well
Can - 7 thought he had a decent game myself
Wijnaldum - 7 ditto
Chamberlain - 7 played well and scored a vital goal
Mane - 6.5 understandably rusty but we are a better team with him in the side
Firmino - 8 his best performance in a while
Salah - 8.5 two goals and another fine peformance

West Ham vs. Liverpool player's average (by 5 voters):

Mignolet - 5.6

Gomez - 6
Matip - 6.8
Klavan - 6.3
Moreno - 6.5

Can - 6.2
Wijnaldum - 6.8
Chamberlain - 7.1

Salah - 8.9
Mane - 7.3
Firmino - 7.9


Newkit man of the match: Mohamed Salah
Newkit flop of the match: Simon Mignolet

Liverpool 3-0 Southampton

Mignolet -7
TAA- 7
Lovren-7
Klavan-7
Moreno- 7.5
Hendo- 7
Wijnaldum-7
Coutinho-8
Salah-9
Mane-7.5
Firmino-7.5

Subs

Can- 6.5
Ox- 6.5
Milner- 6.5


Van Dijk-7 Thought he played well

I know the thread is dead but I just feel like posting my ratings

Karius - 4 - can't really remember a single positive moment from him today. Awful reaction for the first goal. Don't see any potential in this guys whatsoever.
Gomez - 5 - had a good game overall but is equally at fault for the first goal as Karius. Not the first time he switches off like that either.
Matip - 6.5 - solid most of the game, can't really rate him higher with 3 goals conceded though
Lovren - 6 - did ok but just not good enough for this team. Should have done better for the third goal
Robertson - 9 - my new favourite player, didn't put a foot wrong. Gets bonus points for how well he handled that little Sh*t Sterling
Can - 8 - too sluggish when with the ball for my liking but really took control of that midfield today
Wijnaldum - 7.5 - not as good as Can but Gini was also key for winning the midfield battle today
Chamberlain - 8.5 - showed real heart today and took his goal well. Who said he had no end product
Salah - 7 - played well but was also well marked most of the game. Still managed to score a wonderful goal
Mane - 7 - same as Salah. Great finish for the goal
Firmino - 7.5 - worked really hard as usual, fought well for the goal and finished it nicely

Subs:
Milner - 5 - shouldn't have been brought on, completely messed our rhythm IMO.
Lallana - n/a
Klavan - n/a

(overall ratings)

Karius 5 - for their first goal.
Gomez 6
Matip 6
Lovren 5
Robertson 9- kept sterling quiet.
Can 7.5
Wijnaldum 8.5
Oxlade-Chamberlain 8
Mane 7.5
Salah 7.5
Firminho 8