Liverpool FC Forum

Mignolet -2
Gomez-5
Matip- 3
Lovren- 0
Moreno-4
Henderson-3
Milner-3
Can-2
Coutinho-5
Salah-6
Firmino-5

Ox- 5
Stduge- 3

Mignolet -2 I have possibly for my sins been one of his biggest advocates ,but some players simply aren't worth defending.
Gomez -6 Our best defender,acquitted himself well when all around him wilted.
Lovren -2 Fuckwit seems a tad harsh ,but 'through gritted teeth' it sums up his complete abandonment of thought
Matip - 4 There seems to be an outbreak of Lovrenitus, a virus that is now sadly airborne.
Moreno 5 Crossing was poor,but he was decent enough at the back.
Henderson-6 Huge ball for Salah ,and done all he could, but he will never provide even adequate protection for the back four,time to remove the shackles and let him push up.
Can -2 How a player tasked with controlling the middle can be that prone to sleeping on the job is beyond me.
Milner-3 Hopefully the clamor from fans to play him in our midfield has quelled somewhat and the realization has hit home that his midfield days are now firmly behind him.
Coutinho-5 Lost the ball repeatedly but was marked well ,but his saving grace is that he gave his all.
Firmino-5 Chased the ball down and worked hard to defend but his effort is never in question it's his quality we want to see return.
Salah-7 Never stopped running and our best player by a country mile.

Mignolet 2 - absolutely useless at dealing with crosses. He gives no confidence to the defence..

Gomez - 4 He had a ok game I suppose.

Lovren - 2 hope that's his last game in a red shirt.. He was garbage from the start.

Matip - 3 he was ***** aswell as Lovren but Lovren made him look like Maldini.

Moreno - 4 His crossing is below par but he's got good recovery pace to make up for his mistakes. Still not good enough.

Henderson - 4 He looks lost at the moment .. and when he's the captain it's a worrying sight.

Can - 3 He's strolling through games without a care in the world.

Milner - 3 he's always been rubbish in the middle.. He's a plodder and he's too slow for that role.

Coutinho - 5 poor first half due to Spurs doubling up on him. Tough game but at least he tried.

Firmino - 5 ran his socks off for the team.. but do we need this from our striker? We need a goalscorer.

Salah - 7 the only positive from the transfer window.. He must be wondering what kind of team he's joined.

Tottenham vs. Liverpool player's average (by 6 voters):

Mignolet - 2.8

Gomez - 5
Matip - 3.8
Lovren - 1
Moreno - 4.5

Henderson - 4.7
Can - 2.8
Milner - 3.5

Salah - 6.7
Coutinho - 5.5
Firmino - 4.8

Subs (by 4 voters):

Chamberlain - 5.5
Sturridge - 3.5
Grujic - n/a

Newkit man of the match: Mohamed Salah
Newkit flop of the match: Dejan Lovren

Cheers mate.
Those are some of the lowest average scores that I've seen, right across the board as well.
It was an awful performance though.

Liverpool v Huddersfield.
Mingolet 6. Absolutely nothing to do.
Gomez 7. Excellent game from Joe. Tidied up nicely today.
Matip 6. Should have done better with his headers at the other end.
Klavan 6. Bit shaky at times but expected due to lack of match awareness.
Moreno 6. Falls over far too easy.
Henderson 6. Hit a few Hollywood passes before one worked out.
Milner 7. Good enough game but deteriorates quickly 2nd half.
Wijnaldum 7. No stopping that pile driver.
Salah 6. Good game from mo but poor penalty.
Sturridge 7. Nice to see him hit that milestone before he retires 
Firmino 7. A lot of hard work and got rewarded with the goal but man those celebrations suck 

Chamberlain 6. Did well.
Can 6. He isn't signing so shouldhave brought Grujic on.
Solanke 5. Not a lot of time really.

Motm goes to Gomez as he is continuing to hold down a starting role. Overall it was a poor game and the 1st half was uneventful but second half we found spaces and put the game out. A welcome 3 points 

Liverpool v Huddersfield.
Mingolet 6 Unemployed.
Gomez 6 ,no idea why everyone is raving about him ,had no defensive work to do and hardly made significant runs to support the attack...oh well.
Matip 7 ,Unemployed ,love his direct forward movement of the ball (pay attention Hendo) ,should have scored from the Corner kicks.
Klavan 6 Unemployed
Moreno 6 See Gomez..Settled for short wide passing with no support to the attacking play ,Where the Fck is Robertson?
Henderson 6 Boring Hendo ,sage wide passes really killed us at the first half.
Milner 6 Boring as Hendo ,good corner kicks.
Wijnaldum 7 For the goal and for the smile ,also the only one in the MF which actually took the ball forward.
Salah 7, active and involved as always ,poor penalty.
Sturridge 7 ,Only for the good taken goal ,thought he was slow and rusty.
Firmino 7 ,For the goal.

Chamberlain 6.5
Can 6
Solanke 6

Mignolet -4 After his dereliction of duty he needed to be dropped ,so my score reflects my disappointment with him retaining his place.
Gomez -7 I thought the lad 'with the little he had to do' dealt with the threat of the long ball into our box and marking Ince diligently.
Matip -6 Should have scored two really .
Klavan -4 His passing was all over the place in the first 10 min's, including a slip that left us vulnerable
Moreno -4 One good cross the whole game and gave the ball away countless times with some of the worst passing Ive seen from him ,surely Robertson would be a better option
Henderson-5 Looks like he's played a full season already ,Blu tack would hold our middle together better.
Milner -6 Another player I was disappointed in seeing in the line up and the first half confirmed my reservations,good at corners though. 
Wijnaldum -7 great goal and battled hard across an under performing midfield.
Salah -6 Way too much onus being placed on him of late
Sturridge -5 Still some way off ,but the goal may spur him on .
Firmino -7 Our best presser of the ball and well taken flick on for the goal and he was playing out of position.

Liverpool vs. Huddersfield player's average (by 3 voters):

Mignolet - 5.3

Gomez - 6.7
Matip - 6.3
Klavan - 5.3
Moreno - 5.3

Henderson - 5.7
Milner - 6.3
Wijnaldum - 7

Salah - 6.3
Sturridge - 6.3
Firmino - 7

Subs (by 2 voters):

Chamberlain - 6.2
Can - 6
Solanke - n/a

Newkit man of the match: Georginio Wijnaldum
Newkit flop of the match: Simon Mignolet, Ragnar Klavan and Alberto Moreno

Jesus lads, I know we weren't the most convincing (despite winning 3-0) but if someone looks at these scores without knowing the result of the game might think we got thrashed in this one! An average score of 5.7 for the defence + goalkeeper after keeping a clean sheet is ridiculous really.

Anyway, thanks for the kind words everyone. I'll keep doing the averages as often as I can

Nice one mate 

LIVERPOOL v Maribor

Karius - 6 didn't have much to do but did make one good save from a piledriver from distance.
TAA - 6 did okay, delivery into the box could have been a bit better though
Matip - 7 played well
Klavan - 7 ditto
Moreno - 7.5 one of our better players I thought, made some good recovery tackles and should have had an assist
Wijnaldum - 6 did okay but wasn't on long enough to judge properly
Can - 8 started slow (passing a bit too conservative etc) but got better as game went on, scored a great goal and worked hard right to the final whistle
Milner - 7.5 like Emre improved as the game wore on, missed a pen but great assist.
Salah - 8 typical Mo, missed a sitter, scored a vital goal and was generally one of our better players
Firmino - 7 some nice link up play and won a pen
Chamberlain - 6 didn't do anything wrong, decent performance

Karius - 6
TAA - 7
Matip - 7
Klavan - 7
Moreno - 7
Wijnaldum - 6
Can - 7
Milner - 7
Salah - 8
Firmino - 7
Chamberlain - 6

ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Thu Nov 02, 2017 12:11 am wrote:Nice one mate 

LIVERPOOL v Maribor

Karius - 6 didn't have much to do but did make one good save from a piledriver from distance.
TAA - 6 did okay, delivery into the box could have been a bit better though
Matip - 7 played well
Klavan - 7 ditto
Moreno - 7.5 one of our better players I thought, made some good recovery tackles and should have had an assist
Wijnaldum - 6 did okay but wasn't on long enough to judge properly
Can - 8 started slow (passing a bit too conservative etc) but got better as game went on, scored a great goal and worked hard right to the final whistle
Milner - 7.5 like Emre improved as the game wore on, missed a pen but great assist.
Salah - 8 typical Mo, missed a sitter, scored a vital goal and was generally one of our better players
Firmino - 7 some nice link up play and won a pen
Chamberlain - 6 didn't do anything wrong, decent performance

Chamberlain - 40M. "Didn't do anything wrong". I should F'kin hope not at that price. Someone remind me why we paid more than 5M for him again....

bunglemark2 » Thu Nov 02, 2017 2:27 pm wrote:

ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Thu Nov 02, 2017 12:11 am wrote:Nice one mate 

LIVERPOOL v Maribor

Karius - 6 didn't have much to do but did make one good save from a piledriver from distance.
TAA - 6 did okay, delivery into the box could have been a bit better though
Matip - 7 played well
Klavan - 7 ditto
Moreno - 7.5 one of our better players I thought, made some good recovery tackles and should have had an assist
Wijnaldum - 6 did okay but wasn't on long enough to judge properly
Can - 8 started slow (passing a bit too conservative etc) but got better as game went on, scored a great goal and worked hard right to the final whistle
Milner - 7.5 like Emre improved as the game wore on, missed a pen but great assist.
Salah - 8 typical Mo, missed a sitter, scored a vital goal and was generally one of our better players
Firmino - 7 some nice link up play and won a pen
Chamberlain - 6 didn't do anything wrong, decent performance

Chamberlain - 40M. "Didn't do anything wrong". I should F'kin hope not at that price. Someone remind me why we paid more than 5M for him again....

Because we were smoking much better sh1t 

Liverpool vs. Maribor player's average (by 2 voters):

Karius - 6

TAA - 6.5
Matip - 7
Klavan - 7
Moreno - 7.2

Can - 7.5
Milner - 7.2
Wijnaldum - 6

Salah - 8
Chamberlain - 6
Firmino - 7


Newkit man of the match: Mohamed Salah

no flop

Westham 1-4 Liverpool

Mignolet-6- Can still make some daft decisions at times
Moreno-6.5- Decent performance
Matip-7 finally scores can easily help the goal tally like Sami hyypia if he can convert his chances sometimes
Klavan 6.5
Gomez- 6- was at fault for their goal still young needs more exp
Wijnaldum-7 -Looked strong good game
Can-7- same as Wij
Ox-7.5 -much better from Ox and good to see him on the scoresheet
Salah 9- two goals what more can you ask for
Mane 8- Was threatening assisted salah had a good game
Firmino 7.5- Linked well with the lads

Subs

Milner- 5
Solanke -5
Lovren N/A