D___C wrote:There are three great commentators
Alan Green - BBC Five Live
Martin Tyler - Sky
Clive Tyldsley - ITV
Quite a few great games with these three... Tyler in the Collymore 4-3, Tyldsley in Istanbul.
John Motson was dreadful. Awful voice, scripted, nerdy type. Constantly makes errors, and came up with cringeworthy nonsense.. "the sausages will be sizzling back home I should think"... i wanted England to lose almost because of him.
clive `that night in barcelona` tyldsley is a united fan, he`s from the greater manchester area and grew up watching them, martin `yes, yes, yes for manchester united` tyler isnt a manc but he may as well be.
motson is a bit of a wet blanket but he`s also a legend of broadcasting, commentating on games only started in the mid 60`s and motson started on the telly in the early 70`s, the likes of motson and jimmy hill may not be everyones cup of tea but they are pioneers of broadcasting. things what we take for granted these days like having players and managers as studio guests, slow motion replays, co-commentators, goal of the month and goal of the season competitions, interviewing players and managers after the game, putting team line ups on the screen before the game etc were all thought up and pioneered by the likes of hill in the mid to late 60`s and early 70`s.
people like motson, barry davies, david coleman, brian moore etc are legends, classic lines rolled off their tongues, modern commentators are manufactured just like the `classic lines` that they obviously thought up the night before.
edit - this was nearly half a century ago but they talk more sense and are more entertaining than the automatons you get on the telly these days...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=endscreen&v=lTGWnDLNiRw&NR=1 - man city coach malcom allison telling spurs and england star alan mullery that he wasnt that good a player
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qOEDiBNPu00&feature=endscreen&NR=1 - allison again discussing george best breaking pardoe`s leg
note jimmy hill in both clips, he was the fella that brought interviews and analysis into footy coverage