Although no end of you will disagree, and bearing in mind I have thought this for a while - I believe Xabi Alonso is Liverpool's best player.
Stevie G has the swash-buckling adventure-type-style, while Alonso just dictates the pace of the game, stops an unbelievable amount of opposition attacks despite staying on his feet, and creates so many chances for goals that you'd need a calculator by half time!
I know JC is a brilliant defender, and SG is our top scorer and a true powerhouse with skill to boot, but lets be honest - Xabi has it all.
LFC top 5 players (overall ability)in decending order, as I see it:
Alonso
Gerrard
Carragher
Hyypia
Hamann.