by bigmick » Thu Nov 17, 2005 8:07 am
Sorry but I don't agree. I think it shows a lack of respect for your opponent, which is sort of OK at club or provincial level but not when it's on an International stage. It's the equivalent of the Aussies doing a "baggy green" ceremony at Lords for a debutant, Ian Healy presenting the nervous incumbent with his sacred headgear and the sparse crowd breaking into a verse of "Ian Healy, he's a w@nker, he's a w@nker". You just don't do it.
The haka was a wardance around the time of it's conception, in the same way that lots of marching band music was the tune played before battle and designed to ready the men for the kill. These days however it is little more than an opened out huddle, a part of the special spectacle when going to watch in particular the All Blacks perform.
It does us no credit whatsoever that we (the English) were the first to disrespect our opponents in this way. We had some idiot hooker from the West country who took to walking upto the half-way line and "confronting" the haka eyeball to eyeball. How sad it is when people are asked to do the most simple thing, namely stand there and shut up for a minute that they are unable to restrain themselves. Like the fool who breaks the minutes silence for the thrill of hearing his voice echo around the stadium or boos opposition National Anthems, disrespecting people and rituals cannot be right.
I know this. If I took my little lad to a rugby match in which New Zealand were involved and found that they had dropped the Haka as nobody took it seriously or paid it any respect anymore I would not be sending my thanks to that fat fool from Bristol, nor indeed to the fans from down under either.
"se e in una bottigla ed e bianco, e latte".